Welcome to M&M Pickles - Spicy & Crunchy Pickles.
The BEST
pickles around
Welcome to M&M Pickles - Spicy & Crunchy Pickles.
The BEST
pickles aroundWelcome to M&M Pickles - Spicy & Crunchy Pickles.
The BEST
pickles aroundWelcome to M&M Pickles - Spicy & Crunchy Pickles.
The BEST
pickles around
As the seasons change so does our inventory. If we don't have it in stock it means we can't get the raw materials or its out of season. We always do our best to keep a core selection of flavors. If you don't see a flavor on our website it doesn't mean we don't have it. Best to contact us for specific items you are looking for. Sometimes we only do a small batch and may only have limited amounts or we have sold out and are making more.
Delivery
We will delivery locally in Buffalo for any orders over $40 for FREE! We do need a few days notice .
Shipping
If you wish to have pickles shipped we can do that! Just contact us directly through email, text or phone call to arrange it. Because our inventory changes so quickly we do not currently offer totally online shipping.
Check our Facebook and Instagram pages frequently to see where we are selling in person or visit us
We do a lot of events and farmers markets and festivals in and around Buffalo all year round. Please check our social media pages for details.
PICKLE PRICES
Dill Selections
From plain to set your pickle on fire!
16/32oz Jar Dill Pickles
12/18
This jar is just your classic dill pickle. No heat just a lot of flavor and crunch!
16/32oz Jar Garlic Pickles
12/18
For our garlic lovers our garlic pickles have two cloves of garlic in our pint size jars and four in our quart size jars. No heat in these ones, just a great garlic flavor.
16/32oz Jar Mild Pickles
12/18
Our mild pickles have a decent amount of banana peppers in each jar that give a bit of spice to the pickle. We try to get a consistent level of heat by mixing the peppers together before adding to the jars. Mild to medium level of heat.
16/32oz Jar Garlic Mild Pickles
1218
For our garlic lovers who like a little heat, our garlic mild pickles have a generous helping of banana peppers plus two cloves of garlic in our pint size jars and four in our quart size jars. Mild to medium level of heat.
16/32oz Jar Medium Pickles
12/18
Our medium pickles have the perfect amount of freshly sliced jalapeño peppers that give a nice kick that will stay with you. Medium to hot level of heat.
16/32oz Jar Garlic Medium Pickles
12/18
For our garlic lovers who like a little more heat, our garlic medium pickles have a generous helping of jalapeño peppers plus two cloves of garlic in our pint size jars and four in our quart size jars. Medium to hot level of heat.
16/32oz Jar Hot Pickles
12/18
Our hot is made with freshly sliced red fresno peppers. Packed with flavor. Definitely hotter than the medium and very crunchy! Hot level of heat.
16/32oz Jar EXTRA Hot Pickles
12/18
Our extra hot will blow your socks off and definitely set your pickle on fire! A huge helping of serrano peppers in the jar make these pickles something to be very careful with! Extra hot level of heat.
16/32oz Jar Buffalo Punch Pickles
12/18
Our Buffalo punch pickles have a mixture of jalapeños, serrano peppers, habanero and fresno peppers. These peppers give a great flavor and heat. Even hotter than our extra hot! Extra, extra level of heat.
Specialty Products
Our specialty products are not always in stock. Specialty products include: carrots, asparagus, onions, beets, pickled garlic, beans, olives, eggs. For ordering these you need to email us directly to check inventory. We rotate many of these throughout the seasons and usually sell out quickly.
Sweet Selections
From classic bread and butter to extra hot!
16/32oz Jar Basic Sweet Pickles
12/18
This is your classic bread and butter pickle. Lots of crunch in a sweet, tasty brine.
16/32oz Jar Sweet Heat Pickles
12/18
This is your basic sweet pickle with a hint of banana pepper. We slice them up fresh for a slight amount of heat. Mild level.
16/32oz Jar Sweet Burn Pickles
12/18
This has some jalapeños added to kick it up a notch. Medium/hot level of heat.
16/32oz Jar Sweet Fire Pickles
12/18
This sweet mixture has some definite heat to it. Our crunchy pickles mixed with serrano peppers. Extra hot level of heat.
Mixed Gift Bag
Mix and match any of our flavors in one gift bag. Pick out six of our current stock. Changes weekly.
Combination of 6 - 8oz Jars
40
You can combine 6 different 8oz jars of what we currently have in stock to make one fun gift bag of delicious pickles!
ONE CHIP CHALLENGE JAR - SOLD OUT!!!!!
Get your friends together to give this one chip challenge jar a go! If you can handle the heat!
Limited Time Only
20
We created this jar for all our lovers of heat out there. Put your mouth to the test with this 8oz jar of 8 thick cut pickle chips. Loaded with carolina reaper, Trinidad scorpion, ghost and chocolate habanero peppers! Not for the faint of heart. Meant to be shared amongst friends.
About Us
Our Products
We specialize in making spicy pickles. We have a variety of heat levels from plain, all the way up to set your pickle on fire hot!!! We are always coming up with new flavors and things to pickle so check back often.
Our Story
Created by father and son, Mark and Matthew to satisfy their own personal craving for some hot, crunchy pickles. There has now been a demand created for these so we just keep making them. You can find us at our own store to see us in action. We are also at several local farmers markets and small retail stores and various festivals. If yo
Created by father and son, Mark and Matthew to satisfy their own personal craving for some hot, crunchy pickles. There has now been a demand created for these so we just keep making them. You can find us at our own store to see us in action. We are also at several local farmers markets and small retail stores and various festivals. If you like pickles with a lot of flavor you will LOVE these ones! Message us to get some and we will make sure they end up in your hands! Our door is always open for new customers so don’t be shy.
Happy to hand out tastings!!!
Our Mission
Our Mission
To satisfy that craving for heat, dill/sweet and crunch all in one tasty package! You create how to use them. We highly encourage recipe sharing and experimentation. You won't be able to stop thinking of ways to incorporate these yummy pickles into just about every meal!
Reviews
J Trost, Buffalo NY
Alisha Parente, Buffalo NY
Sammy Tiranno, Buffalo NY
"So...I F'ing LOVE pickles, been my go-to snack since childhood. My girl brings me pickles from wherever she goes, because I love em'. Then the one day she comes back with a jar of among THE BEST pickles I've ever had, & low & behold
it's a LOCAL company, LoL
These things are great, perfectly seasoned & PERFECTLY crunchy, they're just te
"So...I F'ing LOVE pickles, been my go-to snack since childhood. My girl brings me pickles from wherever she goes, because I love em'. Then the one day she comes back with a jar of among THE BEST pickles I've ever had, & low & behold
it's a LOCAL company, LoL
These things are great, perfectly seasoned & PERFECTLY crunchy, they're just terrific. It's hard to screw up pickles, I have them from far & wide, & they're all pretty much uniformly good. But these are GREAT. So good, that I searched out this review field, so I could opine, which I haven't done before, but is warranted here. Seriously, order some of these pickles...you'll thank me."
Sammy Tiranno, Buffalo NY
Alisha Parente, Buffalo NY
Sammy Tiranno, Buffalo NY
"These pickles are awesome. When I opened my first jar, I loved them immediately, but then an unfortunate thing happened: while I was thinking about how good they would taste on a sandwich or burger, I became so distracted that I finally realized that the only thing I would ever have them on is a fork -- I ate the whole damn jar in one sitting! Keep em coming!"
Alisha Parente, Buffalo NY
Alisha Parente, Buffalo NY
Alisha Parente, Buffalo NY
"Super delicious pickles. We purchased spicy, sweet, and a couple other products. We took all products to a family dinner, they were all devoured way to quickly. Either I didn't realize how much everyone I know loves pickles or these are way better than your average pickle... my guess is the second one."
Jamie Decker, Buffalo NY
Kristen Bodenstedt, Buffalo NY
Alisha Parente, Buffalo NY
"Best pickles ever!
Thick, crispy, juicy, perfect flavor!"
Jillian Nassivera, Buffalo NY
Kristen Bodenstedt, Buffalo NY
Kristen Bodenstedt, Buffalo NY
"These pickles are absolutely amazing.
Hands down favorite pickles out there.
Amazing crunch and flavor!!
Would 1000% recommend to anyone."
Kristen Bodenstedt, Buffalo NY
Kristen Bodenstedt, Buffalo NY
Kristen Bodenstedt, Buffalo NY
"I just bought a jar of pickles at a local farmers market. I was told that most of their sales come from repeat customers. I got home, cracked open the jar and I 100%believe it! I regret not buying the bigger jar. I'm hooked and will absolutely be back!"
Social
Contact Us
Better yet, see us in person!
Email us at setyourpickleonfire@gmail.com or check social media to see where we are going to be selling next or come see us at our storefront
located at 6995 Transit Rd. in East Amherst. Located just past North French at
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.